The 5 best baby bottles 2017

When you’re looking for the best bottle for baby, it turns out that there are a lot more options than you might expect. Baby bottles come in a variety of shapes and sizes and make all kinds of claims about easier feeding and happier babies. But what do you actually need?

You might find that baby makes the decision for you: some babies just prefer particular bottles. And if you’re using a breast pump it makes sense to get bottles from the same brand, as they’ll fit the pump. It’s worth checking that your proposed bottle can take different sizes of nipple (the bottle’s, not yours!) as baby gets hungrier: what’s fine for a newborn will frustrate a bigger baby.

Be wary of claims about colic, the mysterious malady that makes babies cry after feeding: nobody really knows what causes it, let alone how to stop it. But it does seem that bottles with angled tops or air vents can reduce bubbles in milk, which reduces wind and results in less traumatic feeding.

Most plastic bottles are now BPA-free after a scare over the chemical leaking into liquids, and you’ll find glass and stainless steel options too. We find plastic the best all-rounder: you can heat it, it’s easy to clean and dishwasher safe, and it’s tough enough to survive the many drops it’ll experience in everyday use.

1. Dr Brown Natural Flow Options

The famous anti-colic bottle remains a good choice for any baby

Size: 150ml or 270ml | Vented?: Yes | Material: Plastic | BPA free?: Yes | Microwave?: No | Dishwasher?: Yes

Vent or no vent options
Many happy customers
More parts = more cleaning
Will they fit your sterilizers?

Dr Brown’s bottles introduced an internal vent to reduce air and hopefully make baby’s feed happier, and the latest version gives you the choice of vented or vent-free feeding. Microwaving the bottles isn’t recommended - not just for Dr Brown’s, but for any bottles; microwave heating can be uneven and create hot spots in milk - but they’re dishwasher safe and easy to clean by hand. The plastic is more than capable of withstanding drops too. The bottles come in two sizes, with the smaller one intended to be used as a vented bottle and the larger unvented as baby outgrows colicky symptoms, and there are five nipple sizes: from 0 months, from 3 months, from 6 months and two options for babies 9 months and older.

2. Chicco Natural Feeling

Angled top for a more natural feeding position

Size: 150ml or 250ml | Vented: Yes | Material: Plastic | BPA free?: Yes | Microwave?: No | Dishwasher?: No

Angled for more natural position
Easy to clean
Some silly prices out there
Nipple prone to collapsing

Chicco is one of the bigger baby brands, and its Natural Feeling range promises to reduce colicky symptoms by combining air vents with (optional) angled teats. That offers a more natural feeding position for baby, and because the top of the bottle remains full of milk throughout feeding it reduces the amount of air that baby is likely to gulp. The bottles are easy to clean by hand but dishwashing isn’t recommended and microwaving is a no-no too. Both straight and angled teats come in four versions: from birth, from 1 month, from 3 months and from 6 months. We’d go for the angled ones, though: there are stacks of mums and dads out there who feel the angled versions made feeding easier and did help minimise colic.

3. Tommee Tippee Closer To Nature

They’re everywhere, and in every conceivable configuration

Size: 150ml or 260ml | Vented: Yes | Material: plastic | BPA free?: Yes | Microwave: No | Dishwasher: not recommended

Available everywhere
Widely discounted
Wider than most
Gender specific options - boo!

Many parents try multiple bottles before finding one that makes baby happy, and with our first rather picky baby her clear preference was for Tommee Tippee’s Closer to Nature. Our second took to them from the start, and we like them too: they’re easy to clean, and while they’re not officially dishwasher safe we haven’t had any problems with ours. They’re widely discounted and available everywhere, there are slow, normal and fast flow teats as baby gets older and there’s a clever bottle to cup transition trainer too. It’s just a shame that as well as the familiar white bottles the brand decided to introduce gender-specific pink and blue models. We’re sure they sell well, but what’s wrong with white?

4. Haberman Suckle Feeder

Good anti-colic options but a bit of a faff too

Size: 260ml | Vented: Yes | Material: plastic | BPA free?: Yes | Microwave: no | Dishwasher: No

Works miracles
Great for picky babies
Awkward to clean
A bit of a faff

Many parents come to Haberman after what feels like a war: they’ve tried all the big name bottles but baby still has terrible feeds. And many of those parents come away singing Haberman’s praises while cursing it a little bit too, because while the bottles seem to be very effective at reducing colicky symptoms they’re also fiddly and a pain to clean. However, if you’re having trouble persuading baby to move from breast to bottle then these are definitely worth trying: the relief among Amazon reviewers is palpable. What’s different? The Haberman bottle uses not just a vent but a filter too, and the valve shuts off between suckles to ensure that baby doesn’t ingest any air, and the variable flow system aims to replicate breastfeeding as well as possible.

5. MAM self-sterilising Anti Colic Bottle 3-pack

When you want sterile bottles but don’t have room for a steriliser

Size: 160ml | Vented: Yes | Material: Plastic | BPA free?: Yes | Microwave: Yes | Dishwasher: No

No need for sterilisers
Good value in multipacks
Can leak if not careful
A bit fiddly to clean

The big selling point here is that you don’t need a steriliser: these bottles are designed to be chucked in a microwave with some water and steam-cleaned in seconds. That’s great for small spaces and for travelling, so we’ll forgive the horrible pink and blue options and look at the lilac, green and ivory sets instead. They’re good value for money and it’s never bad to have one fewer baby-specific gadget cluttering up the kitchen, but multiple reviewers point out that you need to be careful when you assemble the bottles as they can leak if you don’t get the lid just-so.